[Who the summary is for]: Our chief operating officer. She has to decide by the end of the month whether to extend the four-day week pilot to more teams, and she will read this summary in five minutes before the leadership meeting. She cares most about service levels and cost.
[The document]: HALVORSEN FREIGHT SERVICES
Four-Day Week Pilot: Six-Month Evaluation
Prepared by People Operations, with input from Finance and Operations
1. Background
In March, Halvorsen began a six-month pilot of a four-day working week for three teams: Customer Service (38 staff), Dispatch Planning (24 staff) and the Eastfield Warehouse (80 staff), a total of 142 people. Staff kept full pay and moved from 40 to 32 contracted hours. Two comparable teams, Billing (31 staff) and the Northgate Warehouse (74 staff), stayed on five days and served as a comparison group.
The pilot had three goals: keep service levels at or above the previous year's, reduce sickness absence and staff turnover, and keep total labour cost within 3 percent of budget.
2. How the teams worked
Customer Service split into two groups with staggered days off, so the phone line stayed open Monday to Friday. Dispatch Planning took Fridays off as a team, with one planner on call each Friday on a rota. The Eastfield Warehouse moved to four ten-hour shifts at first, then, after complaints about fatigue in the second month, to four eight-hour shifts with an extra part-time evening crew.
3. Results
3.1 Service levels
- Customer Service answered 91.8 percent of calls within two minutes, against 92.4 percent in the same months of the previous year. Average customer satisfaction was 4.3 out of 5, unchanged.
- Dispatch Planning delivered 96.1 percent of loads on time, against 95.4 percent the previous year. The on-call Friday planner handled an average of 6 urgent requests per Friday.
- The Eastfield Warehouse picking accuracy stayed at 99.2 percent. Orders shipped per labour hour rose 4 percent, but this partly reflects new scanners installed in May, so the report cannot separate the two effects.
3.2 Absence and turnover
- Sickness absence across the pilot teams fell 22 percent compared with the same months of the previous year. In the comparison group it fell 3 percent.
- Six people left the pilot teams during the six months, against eleven in the same period of the previous year. The comparison group's leavers were roughly unchanged (nine against ten). The numbers are small, so the difference in turnover should be read with caution.
3.3 Cost
- Customer Service and Dispatch Planning stayed within budget. No overtime was needed beyond the existing on-call allowance.
- The Eastfield Warehouse ran 8 percent over its labour budget, mainly because of the extra evening crew and overtime during the switch between shift patterns.
- Across all three pilot teams, total labour cost came in 2.6 percent over budget, inside the 3 percent limit, but only because the office teams were under budget.
3.4 Staff survey
Of the 142 pilot staff, 117 answered the end-of-pilot survey (82 percent). 78 percent want to continue with a four-day week, 9 percent want to go back to five days and 13 percent were unsure. In the warehouse, support was lower: 61 percent want to continue. The most common complaint in the office teams was that Monday workloads were heavier. In the warehouse it was the fatigue and the changing rotas in the first two months.
4. Problems found
- Customer Service coverage on Fridays was thin when two or more people were off sick on the same day. On four Fridays, wait times went above five minutes.
- Some customers were unhappy that their usual dispatcher was not available on Fridays, although the on-call planner handled all urgent requests.
- The warehouse shift pattern changed twice, which unsettled staff and drove most of the extra cost.
- Managers in all three teams reported spending more time on scheduling, about two to three hours a week.
5. Recommendations
1. Make the four-day week permanent for Customer Service and Dispatch Planning, with a rule that no more than one Customer Service agent per group may take leave on a Friday.
2. Do not extend the current warehouse model. Run a second three-month warehouse trial with a fixed eight-hour, four-day pattern designed with the shift leads before it starts.
3. Offer the four-day week to Billing as the next office team, starting next quarter.
4. Review results again after twelve months, including turnover, which needs more time to judge.
6. Limits of this evaluation
The pilot ran for six months, from March to August, which excludes the busy pre-holiday season. Teams volunteered for the pilot, so they may have been more motivated than average. Service and cost figures come from company systems; the survey responses are self-reported.